Thanks WT.
n Holy, if I can adress a couple of points (n i know it's not good to try n counter argue criticism but it's gotta be said^)
you're scoring system seems rather blunt and factual for something that will inevitably be personal opinion.
Firstly, concept...how can you say that its nice to see a vid that fills a niche then give it's concept 6/10 ? surely to consider the concept you wouldnt be taking into account how it is delivered, just the idea in itself, so you either liked the idea or you didnt!
graphics...I'll agree with you on that one, the res was never going to measure up to some of the vids on here and I wanted keep effects etc relatively restrained n didnt try anything that fancy, so yeh 6 is about rite.
music...you can never give a score for music on killvids man, seriously, it is by far the most personal aspect of any vid. I would mark the music on your vid 3/10 like i'd mark most killvids music 3/10 because frankly I hate the music people use in general (apart from Cyn^ that soundtrack was great!) because it's far too weak and washy for what I (emphasis on the I) think should accompany a montage of killing.
I've shown my video to a few people who are into drum n bass and dub-step (dnt kno if you hav that in the states ^) and they loved the soundtrack n said they'd happily listen to it on a CD! But ofc it's down to personal taste so if DnB gives you a headache then, yes you're rite 3/10 prolly fits for
you.
and as far as lasting appeal goes....well if you're gonna want to sit n listen to 8mins of music you cant stand then I doubt you'll be re-watching :]
Thanks for the crtique but dont make it sound so final as if everyone is gonna think that!